Here is an article that I wrote for
For the past three years, I have been working on a project
to create a object oriented interface to the GCC compiler, the GCC Node Introspector
This turned into a perl project after realising the power of perl for handling strings and complex data structures. Also the number of tools that link into perl are amazing.
This linking of programs can to GPL code can be very tricky, and full of problems as a detailed review of the GPL and LGPL can point out.
In this meditation, I will point out what I see as some bumpy spots for Perl and GPL, and clauses that might have been overlooked for too long.
Let us review the the GPL and its implications for linking to Perl :
This General Public License does not permit
incorporating your program into
If your program is a subroutine
library, you may
consider it more useful to permit linking proprietary
applications with the
If this is what you want to do, use the GNU
Public License instead of this License.
is a term that implies
to me containment,
If I write a proprietary program that uses the output of the GPL Code is that containment?
If I open the a pipe to another program, and call
functions in it using data from a GPL program, is
that not what a linker does, but via a different
Lets look at the LGPL 2.1
We use this license for certain libraries in
order to permit linking those
libraries into non-free programs.
When a program is linked with a library, whether
statically or using
a shared library, the combination of the two is
legally speaking a combined work, a derivative of the original library.
The ordinary General Public License therefore permits such linking only if the entire combination fits its criteria of freedom.
The Lesser General Public License permits more lax criteria for linking other code with the library.
Now this does not cover linking via RPC/IPC or Shared
Memory or File.
Let alone CORBA or XML-RPC/SOAP.
This comes done to the definition of linking,
is linking only with the linker, or is linking a
method of passing data between function calls?
Can I call a GPLed Function in GIMP via a perl script
webpage, but I cannot link to it?
LGPL part 2
14. If you wish to incorporate parts of the Library
into other free
programs whose distribution conditions are
incompatible with these,
write to the author to ask for permission. For
software which is
copyrighted by the Free Software Foundation, write to
Software Foundation; we sometimes make exceptions for
decision will be guided by the two goals of preserving
the free status
of all derivatives of our free software and of
promoting the sharing
and reuse of software generally.
LGPL Comment part 2
distribution conditions are
incompatible with these
Does that cover PAL which gives you more freedom. Can I link via perl and all of a sudden, there is no more GPL?
By these terms, every perl script which links in with
GPLed GIMP via script would require such permission to
The perl script is called from an apache server, goes across all types of close-source maybe even patented
software sitting on routers and switches, and then
gets displayed in a microsoft browser, only to call a
draw on some graphic card.
As you can see, the network has changed the meaning of